More Questions Than Answers: COSLA respond to Scottish Government’s plans to reform Local Government

Council leaders have urged caution around Scottish Government’s plans to reform Local Government and called for strong evidence to underpin any significant changes.

Following a meeting of COSLA Leaders yesterday, Cllr Shona Morrison said: “The Scottish Government’s proposals leave more questions than answers.

“It is vital that reforms are based on sound evidence and that meaningful engagement takes place. For that reason, COSLA will participate fully in this period of dialogue to shape the future of local democracy in Scotland.

“If local government is to be reformed, it must be about bringing decisions closer to communities, improving local democracy and delivering better outcomes for all. Significant changes like this must be agreed between Scottish Government and local government and not imposed from the top down.

“Communities must be at the heart of reform. COSLA Leaders are clear that communities and vital staff delivering services day-in-day out must meaningfully inform the future of local services.

“While we all agree on the need for reform, this will not work if it is imposed on councils and the communities they serve so we are calling for Ministers to commit that any changes will be implemented only through agreement with existing local authorities.  This will be an important message to send ahead of next year’s local council elections.

“As councils continue to deliver vital services it is vital Scottish Government works with COSLA to bring clarity to these questions and act on sound evidence.”

Another U-Turn as plans to cancel England’s council elections reversed

‘DEMOCRACY IS NOT AN INEFFICIENCY’

With local government reorganisation looming in England, Local Government Secretary Steve Reed controversially approved delays in 30 council elections in England until 2027.

However Reform UK launched a legal challenge to this decision, and the Government has now been forced to abandon plans to postpone elections after receiving advice that the move could be unlawful.

Florence Eshalomi, Chair of Westminster’s Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee commented on the Westminster Government’s decision to scrap plans to delay 30 council elections in England:

“I welcome this development. As I argued previously, democracy is not an inefficiency that should be cut out during local government reorganisation process.”
 
“Councils should not have been put in the position of choosing between frontline services or elections.

“I welcome the indication that the Government will provide additional resources to ensure that local council elections can take place and look forward to seeing more detail on this”.