Quiet end to 2024 but still a positive outlook for Scottish house prices

Walker Fraser Steele House Price Index for Scotland – November 2024

  • Sales easily outpace 2023
  • Prices in November up only 0.8% on an annual basis
  • Fewer authorities report price rises
  • Average Scottish house price now – £223,094, 0.6% down on October, up 0.8% annually

Scott Jack, Regional Development Director at Walker Fraser Steele, comments: “Scotland’s housing market has seen a gradual recovery in 2024. While house prices have reached record highs in some areas, overall growth has been modest. November saw a slight dip in average prices, down £1,400 (-0.6%) from October, leaving the average price at £223,000—up just 1% year-on-year.

“Only 11 local authorities recorded rising prices in November, with Angus achieving a new record average price of nearly £199,000. This marks the highest average house price ever recorded in the area. Overall, 19 authorities reported higher prices compared to a year ago, though growth has slowed recently.

“Sales activity remained strong, with an estimated 8,800 transactions in November, 10% higher than the previous year. With the Scottish Fiscal Commission forecasting price growth through 2028/29, the market is expected to strengthen in 2025, though tax policy changes and broader economic trends may influence activity.”

Detailed Housing market commentary

Table 1. Average prices in Scotland year to November 2024

Month YearearProperty PriceIndexMonthly % changeAnnual % change
Nov2023£221,272289.8-0.10.0
Dec2023£220,389288.6-0.4-0.5
Jan2024£220,377288.60.00.0
Feb2024£220,333288.60.00.6
Mar2024£222,345291.20.92.0
Apr2024£224,828294.51.12.8
May2024£225,503295.30.32.4
Jun2024£224,715294.3-0.31.7
Jul2024£224,536294.1-0.11.6
Aug2024£225,450295.30.42.0
Sep2024£225,599295.50.11.8
Oct2024£224,450294.0-0.51.4
Nov2024£223,094292.2-0.60.8

Scotland’s housing market has experienced a somewhat unusual recovery in 2024. While house prices nationally have hit fresh record highs on several occasions, the overall pace of recovery of house prices in this country has been modest, impacted by earlier cost-of-living pressures and higher mortgages rates on household budgets.

Figure 1. Year-on-year price gains drift lower

Despite a continuing recovery in sales activity, prices in November fell back by nearly £1,400 (0.6%) compared with October. Following a similar fall in October, average prices now stand a little over £223,000 and are barely 1% higher than a year ago (see Figure 1).

Local Authority prices

Table 2. How prices in November 2024 compare

RankPrior Year RankLocal authorityNov 2023Oct 2024Nov 2024Monthly
% chg
Annual
% chg
1(1)East Renfrewshire£348,574£357,918£354,192-1.0%1.6%
2(2)City Of Edinburgh£337,835£329,469£329,177-0.1%-2.6%
3(3)East Lothian£322,784£333,559£324,453-2.7%0.5%
4(4)East Dunbartonshire£311,192£298,455£298,6330.1%-4.0%
5(5)Midlothian£302,479£285,613£281,995-1.3%-6.8%
6(6)Stirling£282,585£262,939£264,1340.5%-6.5%
7(7)Perth and Kinross£241,373£248,854£254,4032.2%5.4%
8(8)West Lothian£234,717£240,138£239,216-0.4%1.9%
9(9)Highland£231,494£238,581£236,148-1.0%2.0%
10(13)Argyll and Bute£209,522£224,428£225,7680.6%7.8%
11(10)Aberdeenshire£228,712£227,307£224,401-1.3%-1.9%
12(17)Orkney Islands£198,621£219,779£215,408-2.0%8.5%
13(15)Glasgow City£203,633£214,285£212,294-0.9%4.3%
14(11)Scottish Borders£219,369£220,401£211,335-4.1%-3.7%
15(12)Moray£213,017£217,797£210,569-3.3%-1.1%
16(16)Fife£200,544£210,565£207,475-1.5%3.5%
17(14)South Ayrshire£207,358£200,037£199,360-0.3%-3.9%
18(20)Angus£187,485£195,743£198,9731.7%6.1%
19(19)South Lanarkshire£192,904£198,576£196,773-0.9%2.0%
20(24)Renfrewshire£181,050£185,324£187,6621.3%3.7%
21(23)Falkirk£181,388£186,600£185,691-0.5%2.4%
22(18)Shetland Islands£197,602£206,220£183,264-11.1%-7.3%
23(21)Clackmannanshire£185,193£199,279£183,194-8.1%-1.1%
24(22)Aberdeen City£184,173£186,904£181,977-2.6%-1.2%
25(25)Dumfries and Galloway£177,488£176,684£181,4882.7%2.3%
26(28)North Lanarkshire£160,664£170,605£171,7540.7%6.9%
27(26)Na h-Eileanan Siar£177,015£151,392£160,2475.8%-9.5%
28(27)Dundee City£162,816£160,215£159,434-0.5%-2.1%
29(29)East Ayrshire£148,593£149,062£153,8863.2%3.6%
30(30)North Ayrshire£148,265£152,937£149,272-2.4%0.7%
31(32)Inverclyde£135,908£144,997£147,8522.0%8.8%
32(31)West Dunbartonshire£144,788£147,179£146,684-0.3%1.3%
  Scotland£221,272£224,450£223,094-0.6%0.8%


Note: Lines shaded in darker blue reflect cases where Local Authority or Scotland prices reached record highs this month.


Market conditions across Scotland appear to have softened recently. In November only 11 local authorities recorded rising prices in the month while 21 reported price falls.

Angus was the only local authority to set a new market high – nearly £199,000 – in November (see Table 2). Numerous authorities have hit fresh peaks over 2024 and remain within touching distance of them now, whilst Perth and Kinross, where average prices are more than £254,000, is close to topping its previous high set in 2022.

Figure 2. How prices have changed year to November 2004, by local authority

As can be seen from the heat map, a majority of local authorities (19) continue to report stronger prices than a year ago. That said, the net balance of those doing so is noticeably less compelling than we have seen over the past six months or so.

Among the “risers”, six reported price increases of at least 5% over the year. Among these, Inverclyde merits a mention for continuing the strong performance that it began at the start of 2024. At the other end of the spectrum, Na h-Eileanan Siar (formerly Western Isles) which has shown year-on-year weakness since mid-year shared the mantle of significant “faller” with several other authorities in November, e.g., Shetland down -7.3% while in contrast Orkney was up 8.5%.

Transactions analysis

Although we do not yet have the final numbers for October and November, with property sales for the two months not yet fully logged by Registers of Scotland, it is clear that November was another strong month for sales.

Figure 3. Monthly sales over the most recent 12 months compared with a year earlier

Note: Figures for latest two months are Acadata estimates

We estimate that there were about 8,800 sales in the month, about 10% higher than a year ago (see Figure 3). Sales activity has in fact outpaced that of a year earlier in eight of the 11 months of 2024 for which we have data, with cumulative sales for the January-November period tracking 6% above the same period of 2023.

Meanwhile, as Figure 4 shows, sales in the capital and sales of properties worth more than £750,000 (that is, subject to the highest rates of LBTT) continue to be significantly ahead of their corresponding 2023 numbers. Even with incomplete figures for October and November, reported sales of such properties already exceed the full-year 2023 outturns.


Figure 4. Monthly sales in 2023 and 2024, Edinburgh and homes over £750,000


Note: Vertical bars show 2023 sales and horizontal markers show 2024 sales. Figures for October and November 2024 have been greyed out because they are likely to be revised upwards when final Registers of Scotland figures are available.


Despite the somewhat lacklustre year for the housing market it was much better than had been expected by the Scottish Fiscal Commission who had forecast a fall in prices, somewhat akin to many analysts’ views of what might happen south of the border. The RICS housing market survey for Scotland in November was altogether quite positive with agreed sales higher and price and sales expectations up. The general positivity no doubt helped influence the Commission which revised its price forecasts up for future years, with year-on-year growth expected through to 2028/29, the end of their forecast.

Their expectations are not dissimilar to those of other analysts, suggesting the market in Scotland will move ahead in 2025 rather more strongly than it has in 2024, even though we still have one month to report on in 2024.

Having said that the government will be reviewing its Lands and Building Transfer Tax policy during 2025 and that may have implications for activity levels. We must await the outcome first although of course the impact of the higher Additional Dwelling Supplement (ADS) introduced in early December will already be working its way through the market.

Barratt Homes breathes life into former West Lothian hospital site

Barratt Homes East Scotland will soon be welcoming prospective buyers to visit one of the UK’s most iconic redevelopment projects, as homes at Bangour Village, West Lothian launch next month. 

Built on the grounds of former Bangour Hospital outside Livingston, the regeneration of the site is being carried out by a variety of housebuilders, including Barratt Homes and David Wilson Homes which will join in May. 

Earlier this year, Ambassador Group finalised the sale of 14.55 acres of land to Barratt Homes for the development of 179 private residences. The first phase of properties will be available to reserve from February 2025 and includes three and four-bed homes. 

These new homes will become part of the larger Bangour Village Estate, an ambitious redevelopment nestled in 215 acres of woodland. In total, the project aims to introduce up to 998 energy-efficient homes that will benefit from excellent transport links to Edinburgh and Glasgow. 

Once completed, the brand-new community will have a range of amenities including a primary school, nursery, playing fields, a commercial hub comprising a supermarket, café/restaurant, and expansive woodland that has been preserved. 

Lorraine Paterson, Sales Director at Barratt Homes and David Wilson Homes East Scotland, said: “As locals will know, the Bangour site is cherished within the community for its scenic beauty and rich heritage.

“We’ve taken care at every opportunity when designing and planning quality homes on the grounds, making sure properties reflect the needs of families, couples and individuals, while being inspired by the spacious tranquillity of Bangour.

“By working with Ambassador Group and other housebuilders, we hope to see the site reborn as a place to live and thrive.” 

To find out more about Barratt @ Bangour Village, visit:

https://www.barratthomes.co.uk/new-homes/dev002785-barratt-@-bangour-village/ 

For more information on Barratt Homes and David Wilson Homes in the East of Scotland, visit: https://www.barratthomes.co.uk/new-homes/scotland-east/ 

Scottish Housebuilder offering £10,000 Cashback to Edinburgh homebuyers

Kickstart Your New Year with a New Home and £10,000 Cashback from Cruden Homes

Award-winning Scottish housebuilder Cruden Homes is helping homebuyers make a fresh start in 2025 with an exciting new offer – a generous £10,000 cashback on homes reserved at any of their developments from 3rd January until 14th February 2025.

The limited-time cashback incentive is designed to support buyers looking to secure their dream home this new year, providing a significant financial boost to make moving that little bit easier. Whether buyers are looking to move up the property ladder, downsize, or purchase their first home, Cruden Homes’ high-quality, energy-efficient properties offer the perfect solution.

Four outstanding developments in Edinburgh and the surrounding areas are included in this unmissable offer: 

West Craigs Green, Edinburgh: A collection of 122 modern homes featuring apartments, terraced houses, and townhouses. With generous balconies, green open spaces, and excellent transport links, prices start from £220,000.

Wellwater Grove, West Lothian: Three and four-bedroom homes in East Calder, ideally located near local shops, pubs, and cafes, perfect for families and professionals alike. Prices start from £278,500.

Longniddry Village, East Lothian: Traditionally designed two to five-bedroom homes, coach houses, and apartments with standout features like German kitchens, Siemens appliances, and timber sash windows. Prices start from £232,500.

The Avenue, Barnton: Age-exclusive retirement development, designed specifically for the needs of residents over 55 years old,  featuring elegant apartments, penthouses, and villas with on-site facilities, private parking, and EV charging points. Prices start from £365,000.

Hazel Davies, Sales and Marketing Director at Cruden Homes, said: “January is often a time for new beginnings, and what better way to start the year than by securing a beautiful new home?

“Our £10,000 cashback offer is there to make that move a little easier, whether it’s helping with furniture, deposit costs, or something else buyers might need to get settled in their new home.

“With a fantastic selection of homes across our developments, there’s never been a better time to make your move with Cruden Homes.”

Cruden Homes offers a range of thoughtfully designed properties across Scotland, combining style, comfort, and energy efficiency to suit modern lifestyles.

This new incentive extends to all Cruden Homes developments and is expected to appeal to a variety of buyers, including first-time homeowners and growing families, looking to make the most of the new year.

To find out more about the £10,000 cashback offer and explore developments near you, visit crudenhomes.co.uk.

Firethorn Trust secures £29.95m Leumi UK financing for Leith Walk student housing development

Commercial real estate investor, developer and asset manager, Firethorn Trust, has secured a £29.95million debt package from Leumi UK to deliver its first purpose-built student accommodation (PBSA) scheme.

The financing will support the delivery of a 230-bed PBSA project in Leith, which Firethorn acquired in February 2024.

Forming part of the Leith Walk redevelopment scheme, the site has planning permission to deliver a six-storey building featuring high quality accommodation and generous amenities, including a fully-equipped gym, modern study spaces and student common rooms.

Edinburgh’s PBSA market is materially undersupplied, with a student-to-bed ratio of 3.13:1 and a limited development pipeline. The Leith Walk development will help to address demand by creating much-needed bed spaces, while a modern and sustainable design specification will contribute towards BREEAM ‘Excellent’ and EPC ‘A’ ratings.

Richard Whitby, Chief Financial Officer at Firethorn Trust, commented: “The Leith Walk project required a partner that could provide a tailored financing solution to meet our bespoke needs, which is precisely what Leumi delivered.

“We are delighted to be working with Leumi on this development and are excited about the potential for collaboration on future projects as we grow our Firethorn Living platform.

“With our established track record in developing high-quality assets and generating strong returns, we are confident that this development will play a key role in addressing the critical need for modern student housing in Edinburgh’s vibrant university district.”

Dan Whiteman, Relationship Director at Leumi UK, added: “In many ways, this transaction epitomises what sets Leumi UK apart, as we were able to complete this transaction with great focus on ensuring the lending solution met the specific needs of the sponsor.

“Firethorn Trust has a strong track record of creating attractive and sustainable spaces, and we look forward to expanding our relationship as it grows its Living platform.”

The Leith Walk development is expected to complete in time for the 2026/27 academic year.

Firethorn Trust was advised by Brotherton, BCLP and CMS. Leumi UK was advised by Osborne Clarke and MFMac.

For more information, visit www.firethorntrust.com.

Cala Homes unveils trio of new showhomes in South Queensferry

The homebuilder has unveiled a brand new four-bedroom Showhome of Support, as well a three-bedroom showhome and three-bedroom show apartment at Rosebery Wynd

LOCAL businesses from in and around South Queensferry have been put in the spotlight by Cala Homes (East) as it unveiled its second ‘Showhome of Support’ within the area.  

Situated within the homebuilder’s Rosebery Wynd development off Builyeon Road, the impressive four-bedroom Buchanan townhouse showhome has provided a platform for local retailers to promote their wares and showcase the very best that businesses in the area have to offer.  

The initiative forms part of Cala’s South Queensferry Community Pledge – a bespoke package of community support designed to assist with local projects which bring benefit and value to the local community, in a meaningful and measurable way. 

Expertly designed by the team at Show Business, the showhomes feature items from several local businesses from the area, including: Harbour LaneCraigies Farm Beacon StoresLifestoryCatalog InteriorsThe Bonnie HomeAn Independent ZebraEdinburgh MercantileChloe Gardner Art and Ormis.

Jenni Colquhoun, studio manager at Harbour Lane, said: “We were thrilled when Cala approached us to style their new showhome with some of our pieces.

“South Queensferry’s high street is a gem which is filled with unique, vibrant independents that draw people to this truly special area, so it’s fantastic to see a housebuilder of that size celebrating and supporting the businesses at the heart of this community.”

As well as the new Showhome of Support, the award-winning homebuilder has also unveiled a new three-bedroom Balvenie showhome and three-bedroom Almond show apartment which are now available to view at Rosebery Wynd.

Set against the stunning backdrop of the iconic Forth Bridges, each of the homes within this new development offer a unique versatility that suit any lifestyle, with flexible spaces perfect for hosting friends and family, working from home or even transforming into a home gym or hobby room.

Homes within this vibrant new community benefit from all the beauty and convenience South Queensferry has to offer, all while being within easy reach of Scotland’s capital. The development perfectly combines semi-rural and urban city living, with Edinburgh just 20 minutes away by train and excellent commuter links to Fife and beyond.

What’s more, the development is surrounded by plenty of green space and is positioned within close proximity to a number of walking and cycling routes, as well as excellent local schools and a range of amenities, including independent shops, cafes and restaurants.

Elaine Doyle, Sales and Marketing Director at Cala Homes (East), said: “We’re delighted to showcase the incredible talent of South Queensferry’s local businesses through our new Showhome of Support at Rosebery Wynd.

“This initiative is a key part of our South Queensferry Community Pledge, and by featuring locally sourced items from various artisans in our new four-bedroom Buchanan townhouse, we’re providing a unique platform for these businesses to showcase the best of their wares.

“With the addition of our new three-bedroom showhome and three-bedroom show apartment at Rosebery Wynd, we’re excited to offer even more choices for prospective buyers, whether it be first time buyers, downsizers or growing families alike.

“We expect demand for these homes to be high, so I would recommend to anyone who is interested in making the move to South Queensferry to book a viewing appointment with a member of our expert sales team, who will be able to discuss the range of incentives Cala can offer.”

The four-bedroom Buchanan Showhome of Support is available to view now, as well as the three-bedroom Balvenie and three-bedroom Almond apartment. To book a viewing, visit the Cala Homes website or call the sales team on 0131 608 5652.

Prices for two-, three- and four-bedroom homes at Rosebery Wynd start from £249,995 and £434,995. To find out more, visit: www.cala.co.uk/homes-for-sale/scotland/edinburgh/rosebery-wynd-south-queensferry

Cala’s Showhome of Support initiative is one of many activities designed to bring meaningful and measurable benefit to South Queensferry through the town’s Community Pledge.

The housebuilder is currently supporting Queensferry and District Community Council’s (QDCC) ‘Community Chest’, which will see a total of £5,000 distributed to local organisations in 2025.

Groups can apply for up to £1,000 of funding until the deadline on Thursday, 31 December 2024. To apply, visit the application form link on the QDCC website.

To learn more about the South Queensferry Community Pledge, go to: 

www.cala.co.uk/homes-for-sale/scotland/edinburgh/queensferry-heights-south-queensferry/community-pledge

Planning proposals get Britain building and turn the tide on nature’s decline

A new approach to development and the environment will boost the number of homes being built

  • Measures will create a ‘win-win’ for nature and the economy, accelerating economic and environmental growth. 
  • Rules will focus on driving up environmental outcomes over rigid processes that block and delay development, with developers able to pay into a fund for improvements to nature as a quicker and simpler way of meeting their environmental obligations.

Measures to turbocharge housebuilding have been set out (15 December) as part of wider proposals for the forthcoming Planning and Infrastructure Bill.  The Bill will play a key role in promoting economic growth, unlocking a new scale of delivery for housing and infrastructure. 

Common sense changes to environmental rules will support the Government’s commitment to build 1.5 million homes and advance 150 major infrastructure project decisions, while also helping halt and reverse the decline of species and natural habitats. 

A new Nature Restoration Fund would enable developers to meet their environmental obligations more quickly and with greater impact – accelerating the building of homes and improving the environment.

Currently developers may need to secure mitigation for environmental harm before being granted planning permission.

This adds cost, delays and can entirely block the housing and infrastructure our country needs – with rules too focused on preserving the status quo instead of supporting growth and charting a course to nature recovery.

Under these reforms, developers will instead be able to pay into the fund allowing building to proceed immediately – quicker, simpler, and more certain that the broken status quo.

A delivery body, such as Natural England, will then take responsibility for securing positive environmental outcomes, for example, delivering a reduction in nutrient pollution affecting the water environment or securing habitats to increase the population of a protected species.

This represents a shift away from a broken system which has stifled development, growth and nature recovery for far too long – failing communities and the environment. 

Deputy Prime Minister and Secretary of State for Housing, Angela Rayner said: “Getting Britain building means stripping away unnecessary barriers to growth to deliver the homes that we so desperately need.

“For years, vital housing and infrastructure projects have been tied up in red tape leaving communities without the homes, infrastructure and jobs they need.

“Our Plan for Change will put an end to the status quo while restoring nature.  It’s win-win for development and our environment, including targeted reforms allowing us to use the economic benefits of growth to fund tangible and targeted action for nature’s recovery.”

Environment Secretary Steve Reed said: “We were elected on a mandate to get Britain building again and protect nature.

“But the status quo is blocking the building of homes and failing to protect the environment.

“These reforms will allow tens of thousands of homes to be built while protecting the natural environment we all depend on.”   

The proposals set out three steps the government will take to help developers get building while delivering their environmental obligations in a more sensible and strategic way.

This approach will mean developers don’t have to pay for individual site level assessments for the matters covered by the Nature Restoration Fund – which adds cost and delay – and will no longer have to deliver mitigation needed.

A single payment will enable development to proceed. A delivery body will then take the actions needed to drive nature recovery at a strategic, not site-by-site, scale:  

  • Government will lead a single strategic assessment and delivery plan for an area – not an individual site – which will allow decisions to be made at an appropriate geographic scale. The current process is uncertain and costly, with assessments on issues such as nutrient neutrality requiring bespoke calculations and significant technical expertise at the level of each individual project. This also misses the opportunity to support the best outcomes for nature. 
  • A public delivery body will consider which actions are needed to address the environmental impact of development across an appropriate area and determine how much developers will pay into the Nature Restoration Fund. The delivery body will secure the actions funded by developers, removing the need for actions to be taken on a case by case basis. 
  • Contributions will be secured from developers to fully fund nature recovery actions. This would enable developers to meet certain environmental obligations through a single payment into the Nature Restoration Fund – which would streamline the process and maximise the impact of money spent on nature by directing it to real world action instead of paperwork and process.

The proposals are set out in a working paper, which seeks views from stakeholders including communities, housing and clean power developers, nature service providers and local authorities. Feedback from the working paper will inform the next stage of policy development.  

Tony Juniper, Chair of Natural England, said: “It is evident that we need to take urgent action to address the worsening decline of nature, and we must also lean into the challenges posed by housing shortages.

“We will continue to work with the Government to help deliver their plans – but the two key issues of today, nature and economic recovery, should not be pitted against one another, as we step up efforts to avoid losing what protected remnants of nature remain while also restoring some of what has gone. 

“Instead, we should consider the huge opportunities which can be unlocked through better strategic planning which considers environmental improvements, economic development and green spaces for public enjoyment on a landscape scale.” 

Commenting on the National Planning Policy Framework, countryside charity CPRE chief executive Roger Mortlock said: “‘The broken housebuilding market is to blame for the painfully slow delivery of much-needed new homes. When big housebuilders deliberately limit the supply of new homes to maximise their profits, supercharging the current system will not lead to the change the government is looking for.  

‘The government’s plans risk a huge hike in the number of unaffordable, car-dependent homes. Building on England’s 1.2 million shovel-ready brownfield sites would do far more to unlock growth, regenerate communities and provide sustainable, genuinely affordable new homes. 

‘We welcome the commitment to local plans and affordable homes. However, local authorities responsible for delivering new homes will be swamped with speculative applications on high-quality Green Belt and farmland. Inevitably, many of these will be approved to meet nationally imposed targets.  

‘The ‘grey belt’ policy needs to be much more clearly defined and exclude working farms. It will undermine the Green Belt, one of this country’s most successful spatial protections with huge potential to help address the climate and nature emergencies.  

‘There’s some hope ahead with plans for a strategy that covers all our use of land. Longer-term commitments to build genuinely affordable and better designed homes are welcome too. Until then,, our countryside will remain needlessly under threat.’

The government would use the Planning and Infrastructure Bill to introduce legislative changes to drive action at a strategic level which will provide certainty for both developers and the environment.

This will also establish a more efficient and effective way for Habitats Regulations and other environmental obligations to be discharged, pooling individual contributions to deliver the strategic interventions necessary to drive nature recovery.  

‘Bombshell’ report shows short-term lets boost Scottish economy by £864m per year – with no evidence of housing impact

BiGGAR Economics challenges ‘false narratives’ surrounding Scotland’s self-catering sector now at risk from heavy-handed government regulation

NEW independent analysis from a respected Scottish consultancy reveals the substantial positive economic impact of Scotland’s self-catering industry which was also shown to have a negligible effect on housing.

BiGGAR Economics calculated that short-term lets (STLs) contribute nearly £1bn gross value added (GVA) to the Scottish economy while supporting approximately 30,000 jobs. By accommodating visitors, STLs generate economic activity across Scotland, with the local impacts exceeding residential use, supporting an additional £32,400 GVA per property.

Guests staying in self-catering accommodation, termed ‘secondary lets’ in Scottish STL legislation, also spend more than the average visitor to Scotland, with knock-on gains for related tourist and hospitality businesses. Alongside this huge economic boost, the researchers also highlight that self-catering accounts for less than 1% of the country’s total housing stock.

This challenges the narrative that STLs are fuelling Scotland’s housing crisis, with self-catering at only 0.8% of the country’s housing stock, too low a proportion to have a meaningful impact on local housing markets. Moreover, according to the report, in every local authority area, economically inactive empty homes account for a larger proportion of total dwellings than from secondary lets.

The key headlines include:

  • STLs are estimated to generate £864m GVA and support 29,324 jobs across Scotland;
  • Edinburgh and Highland together account for 44% of the total economic impact but the sector’s benefits are dispersed throughout Scotland;
  • The annual GVA associated with an average owner-occupier/private rented household in Scotland was £14,451, compared to £50,159 for a two-bedroom STL; and
  • STLs make up a tiny proportion of Scotland’s housing stock, with self-catering accounting for just 0.8%. This is considerably less than the 3.6% that economically inactive empty properties account for.

This study comes as the Scottish Government published an implementation update report on STL licensing which the industry maintains did not adequately address their longstanding concerns. At a local level, councils such as Highland and Edinburgh are also assessing their regulations.

BiGGAR’s new analysis is based on the best available evidence on STLs in Scotland. The findings have been shared with Scottish Government Ministers and officials.

Graeme Blackett, Director of BiGGAR Economics, said: “This report shows that secondary lets make an important contribution to Scottish tourism and economy overall, supporting almost 30,000 Scottish jobs.

“Our research also concluded that it was clear that secondary lets are not a driver of the wider Scottish housing market.

“If short-term let regulations leads to a reduction in the supply of secondary lets, that will have a negative impact on the tourism economy, without delivering any solutions to Scotland’s wider housing challenges.”   

Fiona Campbell, CEO of the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers, said: “This is yet more compelling evidence that short-term lets aren’t the main contributor of the housing crisis but are instead turbocharging local economies with a near £1bn positive impact while supporting 30,000 jobs.

“The current unbalanced regulatory framework does not reflect this reality and changes are needed before irreversible damage is done.

“Local councils should take heed of the report’s findings when considering their approach to planning policies and control areas to ensure the relatively small number of valuable short-term lets are protected.

For policymakers, the message couldn’t be clearer: you can’t solve a housing crisis by producing a crisis in Scottish tourism by decimating local businesses that underpin local economies. Attention must shift to the real causes of the housing crisis.

Shelter Scotland calls for “immediate intervention” against City of Edinburgh Council after vote to strip homeless households of human rights

Elected and unelected members have shown themselves to be incapable of following the rule of law

  • Charity says it has “lost confidence” that the City of Edinburgh Council will uphold the rule of law and calls on Scottish Ministers and the Scottish Housing Regulator to intervene immediately – the first time the charity has called for special measures to be taken against a local authority
  • City Council acting unlawfully in use of unlicensed HMO accommodation to house some homeless households
  • City’s elected and unelected members voted in favour of suspending lifeline housing rights until March 2028, breaching housing laws they are charged with upholding
  • If the Scottish Government and SHR decide to intervene, it will be the first time that they have exercised the powers afforded to them to protect the housing rights of people experiencing homelessness

Scotland’s leading housing and homelessness charity has today (12 December) called on Scottish Ministers and the Scottish Housing Regulator to intervene against City of Edinburgh Council after the local authority voted in favour of stripping homeless households of their basic rights.

At a meeting of the city’s Housing, Homelessness and Fair Work Committee, councillors voted six to five in favour of proposals to strip people experiencing homelessness of their right to adequate housing through the provision of suitable temporary and permanent housing.

The vote follows confirmed cases of homeless households being placed in unlicensed HMO (Houses in Multiple Occupancy) properties as temporary accommodation – a criminal offence. (2)

In a letter to Scottish Ministers and the Scottish Housing Regulator (3), the charity’s director Alison Watson warned that the Council’s plans are a concerted effort to undermine Scotland’s housing and homelessness rights system and that sanctions must be taken.

She states that: “We cannot stand by and watch efforts to strip people of their housing rights without putting up a fight on behalf of the most disenfranchised people in our communities. Law breaking on this scale cannot be normalised.”

The call comes following the Scottish Government’s reversal of cuts to the affordable homes budget last week after pressure from housing campaigners.

Alison Watson, director of Shelter Scotland said: “It should outrage everyone in Scotland that officers and elected members within a local authority have unilaterally decided to strip people in the capital of a fundamental human right.

“Edinburgh’s homelessness crisis is partly of the Council’s own making, but instead of showing compassion and seeking to help some of the most disenfranchised people in our society, they have chosen instead to punish them in this inhumane way by taking away hard-won rights.

“Shelter Scotland has lost confidence in the leadership of the City of Edinburgh Council to do the right thing and uphold the rule of law. The leadership has systematically failed homeless people for years and is now stripping them of their rights to cover up their own failures.

“I have written to the First Minister John Swinney MSP, urging him to use his powers to call in the council’s homelessness strategy for scrutiny. It is our belief that this will highlight that the current strategy is not only unfit for purpose and cannot guarantee the rights of people at risk of homelessness but is in fact in breach of the law.

“The Scottish Government must do more to fully fund local services through the upcoming budget. However, more money won’t work if the wrong decisions are being taken locally on how to spend it.

“I have also written to the Scottish Housing Regulator as recent assurances provided by the council leadership in their annual statement clearly do not hold up to scrutiny.

Elected and unelected members have shown themselves to be incapable of following the rule of law. They must reverse the committee’s decision or else immediately step aside.”

Shelter Scotland is calling for the Regulator to consider its powers to use sanctions up to an including the appointment of new management in the housing department within the City of Edinburgh Council, under its powers contained in the Housing (Scotland) 2010 Act.

Under Scottish housing legislation, Scottish Ministers have the powers to call the City of Edinburgh Council’s homelessness strategy in for review, including its provision of temporary accommodation.

Alison Watson added: “Shelter Scotland has never called on the Regulator or Ministers to intervene in this way. We do not do so lightly. However, we will not stand by – and nor should the people of Scotland – and watch people’s rights be eroded without a fight.

“We cannot normalise law breaking on this scale. There must be consequences otherwise there can be no prospect that other rights will be protected, nor of the situation improving for the thousands of people in desperate need of a safe and secure home.”

There are currently around 5,250 households in temporary accommodation in Edinburgh. It is estimated that over a quarter (1,488) of these households are living in properties under an Unsuitable Accommodation Order.

Local group keep the pressure on Senior Housing Staff

On 27 November 2024, North Edinburgh Parents Action Group met Edinburgh Council’s Senior Housing Staff including the chair of the housing committee for the second time.

Cases shared with the director of housing

As a result of the group’s work e.g. producing a report, launching an exhibition and organising meetings with senior housing staff, the director of housing requested that the details of all people involved in this project be sent to him so that they could try to resolve all these issues and learn from this.  The group felt that the managers listened to the issues and are trying to understand what is going wrong.

Change is possible

22 cases were sent to the director of housing and his team in October and November. There have been some successes;

  • some people have been rehoused
  • some work on repairs and some dampness issues have been addressed
  • families have been provided with support.  

More needs done

There is still much more work to be done and the group are waiting on a detailed update from the director of housing regarding all the outstanding work.  This should be completed by the next meeting with the parents at the end of February.

Suspension of EdIndex

The group are concerned about the suspension of EdIndex and non-urgent repairs and feel this is going to make the situation even worse.  The group are also concerned that there are not enough larger houses being built at the waterfront and not enough houses for social rent.  Many of these new houses will be out of local people’s reach.

The group heard that no council properties are going to be advertised until 7 Jan 2024 or later.  This is due to the council putting homeless families in unlicensed (illegal) accommodation.  The council need to move these families into long term empty houses (voids) with minimum work done to them apart from minimum Health and Safety checks.

Use Tourist Tax (Visitor Levy) to invest in Housing

The group believe that the tourist tax should be spent on housing where it is most needed (the consultation on the tourist tax ends on 13 December).

https://consultationhub.edinburgh.gov.uk/sfc/visitor-levy

Further Action

Th group told the senior managers that they plan to:

  • raise this issue with the Minister for Housing at the Scottish Parliament
  • explore group legal action as a last resort
  • invite senior managers and the chair of housing to a third meeting at the end of February 2025

Sara, a group member said: “We are serious about keeping up the pressure on the council to ensure people have a safe, warm, damp free home to live in.

Some options that the group are considering include going to the media to highlight people’s stories, taking the campaign to the Scottish Parliament, and contacting a law firm about the possibility of a group action.”

Planning permission secured for 172 new homes at Millerhill

Cruden Homes and Mac Mic Group get green light for landmark Millerhill development

Two of Scotland’s most established property companies, with a combined 181 years of expertise, are set to invest into the thriving community at Millerhill, just south-east of Edinburgh.

Cruden Homes, with 81 years of innovation in homebuilding, and Mac Mic Group, marking its centenary next year, have secured planning consent for 172 energy-efficient new homes in one of Scotland’s most vibrant and best-connected new communities.

The Millerhill development is part of the wider Shawfair masterplan to create a new town on Edinburgh’s doorstep. The new development will include a mix of private sale, build-to-rent, and affordable housing, helping to combat Edinburgh’s ongoing housing emergency.

Work will start in early 2025, with the first phase of homes expected to be completed and ready for residents by the end of the year.

Both businesses have a strong local heritage, having been involved in the delivery of a number of new homes in the area in recent years. This latest development includes a range of houses and flats for private sale, offering an impressive selection of two-bedroom flats, two- and three-bedroom terraced and semi-detached homes, four-bedroom townhouses, and four- and five-bedroom detached properties.

Additionally, a number of houses and flats are to be retained by Mac Mic Group as part of its longstanding rental portfolio, offering an important alternative for home seekers. Thirty-five homes, consisting of six houses and 29 flats, will be affordable, providing much-needed options for local families and individuals.

Nestled in the desirable Millerhill area, this thoughtfully designed development combines the appeal of country living with exceptional transport links to Edinburgh, the Borders, and beyond. Residents will enjoy a new neighbourhood with landscaped streets, carefully planned frontages, extensive landscaping throughout and a tree-lined corridor.

The new homes lie within easy reach of the vibrant new Shawfair town centre, with a health club, offices, shops and places to eat, and are well served by excellent local schools and plentiful landscaped green space, woodland paths and open water. The development is close to Shawfair train station and benefits from a network of cycle and walking paths, providing an abundance of sustainable transport options.

All of the new homes will incorporate a cutting-edge district heating system, providing a low-carbon solution for heating and hot water. This innovative heat network eliminates the need for individual boilers and significantly reduces carbon emissions.

Kevin Reid, Executive Chairman of Cruden, said: “We are delighted to take forward this fantastic new development at Millerhill in partnership with Mac Mic Group. Not only will it deliver much-needed new housing across all tenures, but it will also add to an already vibrant, sustainable community that offers the perfect blend of connectivity, green spaces, and excellent amenities on the doorstep.

“Work will start early next year and will deliver a blueprint for quality, energy-efficient new homes that are perfectly suited to the needs of modern living.”

Andrew Mickel, Group Director of Mac Mic Group, added: “2025 marks our centenary year in the land and property sector and Mac Mic is proud to continue our legacy of quality placemaking on this important development in partnership with Cruden Homes.

Millerhill, and the wider Shawfair area, offers the best of country living, just 15 minutes from Waverley Station, making it an increasingly sought-after neighbour to the Capital.

Edinburgh is facing a well-documented housing emergency, and this innovative new development will be part of the solution, providing a diverse range of high-quality homes, including affordable housing, private rental options, and homes for sale.”