Scottish and Welsh Governments write to UK ministers ahead of Budget

Call to scrap ‘punitive’ welfare policies and cut bills

The Scottish and Welsh Governments have called on the UK Government to scrap “punitive” welfare policies, adopt plans to cut energy bills, and to further devolve powers to help drive continued progress in tackling poverty.

In a joint letter to the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions Pat McFadden and Education Secretary Lucy Powell, Scotland’s Social Justice Secretary and the Welsh Deputy First Minister have urged the UK Government to scrap the benefit cap, bedroom tax and the freeze to local housing allowance – which is widening the gap between housing benefits and real-world rent, driving homelessness and poverty.

The calls extend to pressing the UK Government to adopt Scottish Government proposals for a social tariff in the form of targeted bill discounts, with published modelling showing that 660,000 households in Scotland would see their estimated fuel bills go down by an average of £700.  

The Scottish and Welsh Government signed the Cardiff Agreement last month, pledging to work together on areas including tackling child poverty and the cost of living.

Scotland’s Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville said: “Scotland and Wales are clear – we need to see far more from the UK Government to support people with the cost of living, and to support us in our efforts to end child poverty.

“Scotland is one of the most energy rich nations in the world but we pay some of the highest bills in Europe, already hundreds of pounds higher than was promised when the UK Government came to office. It is causing real hardship across the country and is a key driver of poverty.

“The Scottish and Welsh Governments are also clear that we need more action from the UK Budget to support our work on child poverty – that includes ending the cruel benefit cap which is punishing children for circumstances beyond their control.

“This has never been more pressing, with DWP’s own data showing that the number of Scottish children impacted doubled to nearly 20,000 between March and May this year.

“Our game-changing Scottish Child Payment shows the innovative and ambitious policies we can implement where we have the power.  It shows why we need more powers in Scotland and Wales, rather than seeing them hoarded by the UK Government.

“The UK Government must now take action in their Budget to cut bills and boost living standards.  And if they will not, they should hand the powers over to a Scottish Government that would.”

Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Minister for Social Justice and Equality Sioned Williams said: “We all share the belief that no child’s life should be limited by poverty. Tackling poverty is a priority for this Welsh Government, and we are addressing it in a number of ways including expanded funded childcare, and delivering a new child poverty strategy with meaningful targets.

“While we are taking firm action wherever we can, we need the UK Government to play its part and our joint letter with the Scottish Government calls for a clear set of actions to support us in tackling child poverty. This is not only about those levers which remain with the UK Government but also about supporting us to effectively use our own powers.

“An example of this is the Cynnal child payment in Wales. This can only succeed with the co-operation of the UK Government to ensure that those receiving the payment are not penalised by having their entitlement to other benefits reduced, allowing children and families to receive the maximum possible support.

“I call on the UK Government now to work with us and give us the assurance that we can make a real difference with this scheme.

“Introducing a social tariff is also key, and I join colleagues across in UK in calling for this to be introduced urgently. In many areas such as this it is the UK Government who can make the difference and the budget is the opportunity to do this for families in Wales and across the UK.”

Tackling poverty: joint letter to UK Government Ministers

Call for clarity on National Insurance

48 organisations back letter raising concerns

Scottish public sector and voluntary organisations have come together to raise concerns at the impact of the impending increase to employer National Insurance contributions.

Organisations from across civic society in Scotland have backed a letter to the UK Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves, calling for funding to fully cover the additional costs they face.

At present, the estimated cost to organisations delivering public services in Scotland to cover the increase in employer National Insurance contributions could amount to £700 million.

The joint letter from First Minister John Swinney and COSLA President Shona Morrison has been supported by 48 organisations including the Scottish Trades Union Congress, Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations and British Dental Association. 

The First Minister said: “I would like to thank all the public and voluntary sector organisations who have come together to call in a unified voice for this decision to be reconsidered.

“We are disappointed that the UK Government did not engage with the Scottish Government on the change to employers National Insurance Contributions and we are concerned about the additional pressure it places on all employers. The Scottish Budget is expected to pass within weeks, and alongside local authorities, we need clarity.

“We will continue to press the UK Government to raise our deep concern about the implications of the increase to employer National Insurance contributions for organisations across Scotland, and the risk to the vital services they provide if these additional costs are not fully funded.”

SCVO chief executive Anna Fowlie added: “Coming on top of rising costs and fragile funding, this ill-thought-through rise in the cost of employing staff is a body blow to many Scottish charities. 

“Employers, staff and people receiving vital public services will all be hit hard. It’s unusual to see this range of voices in collective agreement and I hope the Chancellor will reconsider her position.”

The letter has been supported by:

  • Roz Foyer, General Secretary, Scottish Trades Union Congress (STUC)
  • Anna Fowlie, Chief Executive, Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations (SCVO)
  • Martin Green, Chair, Community Pharmacy Scotland
  • Eilidh Thomson, Chair, Optometry Scotland
  • David McColl, Chair of the Scottish Dental Practice Committee, British Dental Association
  • Jacki Smart, Chair, Scottish Hospices Leadership Group
  • Gavin Sinclair, Director of Funding and Partnerships, Venture Trust
  • Wilma Thomson, Manager, Rape Crisis Grampian
  • Sharon Aitchison, Chief Executive, Monklands Women’s Aid
  • Marsha Scott, Chief Executive, Scottish Women’s Aid
  • Lauren McGregor, Children and Young Person’s Team Leader and Independent Domestic Abuse Advocate, Committed to Ending Abuse (CEA Ltd)
  • Susie Stein, Chief Executive, Scottish Borders Rape Crisis Centre
  • Jan Swan, Chief Executive, Fife Rape and Sexual Assault Centre
  • Colin Lee, Chief Executive, Council of Ethnic Minority Voluntary Sector Organisations (CEMVO) Scotland
  • Aaliya Seyal, Chief Executive Officer, Legal Services Agency Ltd
  • Donna Hutchison, Chief Executive, Aberdeen Cyrenians
  • Angela Barron, Chief Executive, Forth Valley Rape Crisis Centre
  • Linda Rodgers, Chief Executive, Edinburgh Women’s Aid
  • Alana Harper, Chief Executive, Tayside Deaf Hub
  • Pam Hunter, Chief Executive, SAY Women
  • Karen Moore, Interim Change Manager, Motherwell District Women’s Aid
  • Shirley Middleditch, Manager, South Ayrshire Women’s Aid
  • Sandy Brindley, Chief Executive, Rape Crisis Scotland
  • Maria Jose Pavez Larrea, Co-General Manager, Grampian Regional Equality Council (GREC)
  • Paul Wilson, Chief Officer, Volunteer Edinburgh
  • Nicola Livingston, Chair, Scottish Council of Jewish Communities
  • Dr Richard Groden, Chair, Jewish Care Scotland
  • Dr Donny Lyons, Co-Chair, Cosgrove Care
  • Sabir Zazai OBE, Chief Executive, Scottish Refugee Council
  • Jane Wood, Chief Executive Officer, Homes for Scotland
  • Catherine Dyer CBE, Chair, Community Justice Scotland
  • Stuart Stevens, Chief Officer, Scottish Fire and Rescue Service
  • Graeme McAlister, Chief Executive, Scottish Childminding Association
  • Jaci Douglas, Chief Executive, Care and Learning Alliance
  • Ben McLeish, Director, 2020 Together
  • Louise Licznerski, Founding Director, Scottish Outdoor Learning Association
  • Irene Audain, Chief Executive, Scottish Out of School Care Network
  • Jonathan Broadbery, Director of Policy and Communications, National Day Nurseries Association
  • Sharon Fairley, Chief Executive, Scottish Private Nursery Association
  • Jane Brumpton, Chief Executive, Early Years Scotland
  • Fraser McKinlay, Chief Executive, The Promise Scotland
  • Francis Scott, Director of Services, St Phillips School
  • Stuart Provan, Chief Executive Officer, Seamab Care and Education
  • Mary Geaney, Chief Executive Officer, Rossie Young Peoples Trust
  • Martin Boyle, Interim Chief Executive, Scottish Funding Council
  • Pauline Radcliffe, Chief Executive, Scottish Credit and Qualifications Framework
  • Graeme Jackson, Interim Chief Executive, Colleges Scotland
  • Frank Mitchell, Chair, Skills Development Scotland 
  • Damien Yeates, Chief Executive, Skills Development Scotland