Tourism: Scottish Thistle Award winners revealed

Kat Brogan, the visionary leader behind one of Scotland’s most progressive tourism businesses has been named as the winner of one of the country’s most prestigious tourism and events awards.

The Managing Director of Mercat Tours took home the Scottish Thistle Awards’ highest accolade, the Silver Thistle, at the national final held at the Hilton Glasgow on Thursday 21 November.

Delivered by VisitScotland, the Scottish Thistle Awards, with headline sponsors Johnstons of Elgin, celebrate the very best of the tourism and events industry. They have become an annual celebration of excellence, collaboration, and innovation within one of the country’s most important sectors. 

The Silver Thistle is awarded in recognition of an outstanding contribution to tourism, an honour bestowed by the industry to someone who delivers stand out work and inspires excellence in others.

Judges said Kat Brogan represented the ‘very spirit of the Silver Thistle Award; a leader whose passion, vision, and commitment to excellence has left a lasting impact on Scottish tourism.’  

Business Minister Richard Lochhead who presented the award said: “It was a privilege to award Kat Brogan the coveted Silver Thistle award, celebrating her commitment to inclusivity and sustainability while showcasing the best of our capital city.

“Tourism is vital to Scotland, providing jobs and highlighting the diversity of Scotland’s offer to global audiences.

“And it is a sector which is passionate about driving positive change on behalf of communities across the country. The Scottish Government is committed to supporting the industry at every step.”

Among the other Edinburgh winners were The Scotch Whisky Experience which took home the award for Best Visitor Attraction, sponsored by Jacobite Loch Ness Cruises. The popular attraction which is based on the Capital’s famous Royal Mile impressed judges with its clear culture for innovation including several examples such as tasting and story-telling experiences. 

Susan Morrison, Chief Executive, said: “We are thrilled and honoured to receive the award for Best Visitor Attraction.

“A huge thanks to our amazing customer-facing and support teams. This award is truly the culmination of everyone working together to welcome the world and help them on their journey to fall in love with Scotch whisky.”

Meanwhile, nearby Camera Obscura & World of Illusions, was named Tourism & Hospitality Employer of the Year.

Judges commended the attraction for its diverse workforce which fosters an atmosphere of dignity, honesty and response. It was also praised for having regular dialogue with staff with lots of opportunity for innovation, training, sharing of ideas and providing feedback.

Andrew Johnston, General Manager, said: We are very grateful to the judges for this prestigious award and to our dedicated team for their tireless efforts.

Their commitment to enhancing our facilities and visitor experience has been invaluable. Thank you to our visitors for continuing to enjoying our unique offer of interactive fun.”

Finally, Business Events Shaping Tomorrow ‘BEST’ Business Event – ACNAP 2023 which took place at the Edinburgh International Conference Centre (EICC) was named Best Business Event.

Held in June 2023, the event welcomed 450 delegates to the Association of Cardiovascular Nursing & Allied Professions’ Annual Conference, bringing together cardiovascular nurses, allied professionals, pharmacists and health care scientists in cardiovascular care. 

The conference was praised for contributing to Scotland’s Cardiovascular Nursing expertise, advancing the quality of life for the people of Scotland, and for showing excellent alignment to Scottish Government Policy aims, sustainability and legacy.

EICC Chief Executive, Marshall Dallas said: “At the EICC, we’re dedicated to hosting impactful business events. ACNAP’s 2023 conference is a brilliant example of how a business event can be a catalyst for positive societal impact, by raising public awareness and driving policy change.

“We’re really proud to see this legacy work recognised with a Thistle Award.”

Steven Walker, Chair of the Scottish Thistle Award Industry Panel, said: “My sincerest congratulations to Kat Brogan, The Scotch Whisky Experience, Camera Obscura & World of Illusions, the EICC and the Association of Cardiovascular Nursing & Allied Professionals, on being crowned winners at this year’s Scottish Thistle Awards national final.

“This is a remarkable achievement and shines a spotlight on the excellent tourism offerings available in the city.

“Earning recognition as one of the best in the country is a fantastic accomplishment. It not only shines a spotlight on the city but also underscores the positive impact our tourism and events industry has on Scotland as a whole. 

 “Winning a Scottish Thistle Award means joining a prestigious roll of honour, placing these winners among the country’s finest and opening doors to new opportunities.” 

The Scottish Thistle Awards champion innovation, collaboration and sustainable practices, in line with the ambitions of the national tourism strategy, Scotland Outlook 2030.      

2024 saw more than 700 entries submitted by individuals, businesses, events and community organisations in the bid to be recognised for the role they play in making Scotland a must-visit, must-return destination.    

The Scottish Thistle Awards are delivered in partnership with Highlands & Islands Thistle Awards (HITA), the Aberdeen City and Shire Thistle Awards (ACSTA) and the South of Scotland Thistle Awards, supported by a panel of industry representatives. 

This year’s national sponsors of the Scottish Thistle Awards include headline sponsor, Johnstons of Elgin, as well as Abbey UK, Jacobite Loch Ness Cruises, The Macallan Estate, LNER, STV, SLTA, Historic Scotland and Fishers. The Scottish Thistle Awards also includes a media partnership with News Scotland including The Times Scotland and the Scottish Sun.    

Full list of winners: 

Category Winners 
Best B&B or Guest House Experience – sponsored by Abbey UK Glenegedale House, Isle of Islay 
Best Bar or Pub – sponsored by Scottish Licensed Trade Association The Cross Keys Inn, Ettrickbridge 
Best Business Event Business Events Shaping Tomorrow ‘BEST’ Business Event – ACNAP 2023, Edinburgh 
Best Eating Experience The Globe Inn, Dumfries 
Best Hotel Experience – sponsored by Fishers Apex City Quay Hotel & Spa, Dundee 
Best Luxury Experience – sponsored by The Macallan Estate Trump Turnberry, Girvan, 
Best Outdoor or Adventure Experience Nevis Range, Torlundy 
Best Self Catering or Unique Stay Kabn, Loch Fyne 
Best Visitor Attraction – sponsored by Jacobite Loch Ness Cruises The Scotch Whisky Experience, Edinburgh 
Celebrating Thriving Communities – sponsored by The Scottish Sun Friends of Dundonald Castle SCIO, Dundonald 
Climate Action Award – sponsored by LNER Glasgow Science Centre, Glasgow 
Inclusive Tourism Award – sponsored by Historic Scotland Trimontium Museum, Melrose 
Innovation in Tourism – sponsored by The Times Scotland Loch Ness Hub and Travel, Drumnadrochit 
Outstanding Cultural Event or Festival – sponsored by STV Wigtown Book Festival, Wigtown 
Outstanding Sporting Event World Athletics Indoor Championships, Glasgow  
Rising Star Award Hannah Cochrane – Scottish Event Campus, Glasgow  
Tourism & Hospitality Employer of the Year Camera Obscura & World of Illusions, Edinburgh 
Tourism Individual of the Year Russell Fraser, Loch Ness Hub and Travel, Drumnadrochit 
Silver Thistle Kat Brogan, Mercat Tours, Edinburgh

Edinburgh tourism stars shine

Two iconic tourist attractions, one unforgettable event, and two inspirational individuals from Edinburgh have received recognition at Scotland’s premier tourism and events awards.  

Five businesses and individuals from the city received awards at the Central and East of Scotland Thistle Awards regional final at Sheraton Grand Hotel, Edinburgh last week (Thursday 26 September).   

The Scottish Thistle Awards, with headline sponsors Johnstons of Elgin, celebrate the very best of the tourism and events industry.  They have become an annual celebration of excellence, collaboration, and innovation within one of the country’s most important sectors.    

2024 saw more than 700 entries submitted by individuals, businesses, events, and community organisations in the bid to be recognised for the role they play in making Scotland a must-visit, must-return destination.     

Winners from across the city include:  

Camera Obscura & World of Illusions which took home two awardsEdinburgh’s oldest visitor attraction was named Tourism & Hospitality Employer of the Year and winner of the Climate Action Award, which celebrates businesses making significant progress towards net zero.  

Judges praised the Edinburgh attraction for its environmental sustainability practices and supportive work environment.  

Andrew Johnson, General Manager at Camera Obscura & World of Illusions said: “We are very grateful to the judges for these prestigious awards and to our dedicated team for their tireless efforts.

“Their commitment to enhancing our facilities and visitor experience has been invaluable. Thank you to our visitors for continuing to enjoy our unique offer of interactive fun.” 

Edinburgh’s Hogmanay 30th Anniversary Celebration won the award for Outstanding Cultural Event or Festival.  

The category recognises the outstanding cultural events and festivals that are part of Scotland’s tourism offering.   

In 2023, Edinburgh’s Hogmanay once again welcomed the world to party in Scotland’s capital, celebrating a milestone 30th anniversary with a spectacular programme of world-class events. Produced by Edinburgh creatives Unique Assembly, over 100,000 revellers partied their way into 2024 at a 4-day carnival of fire, light, music, and dance.  

Edinburgh’s Hogmanay Festival Directors Penny Dougherty, Dani Rae, Nik Whybrew and Al Thomson said: “We are immensely proud that Edinburgh’s Hogmanay has been recognised at the Thistle Awards.

“Reaching a milestone 30th anniversary in 2023, Edinburgh’s Hogmanay goes from strength-to-strength, and we can’t wait to welcome the world to party at the Home of Hogmanay again this year.  

“A huge thank you to the incredible Unique Assembly team and all our event partners who make the festival happen.” 

The Best Visitor Attraction award was presented to The Scotch Whisky Experience with judges impressed by the attraction’s clear culture for innovation including several examples such as tasting and story-telling experiences. 

Susan Morrison, Chief Executive of the Scotch Whisky Experience said: “We are thrilled and honoured to receive the award for Best Visitor Attraction. A huge thanks to our amazing customer-facing and support teams.

“This award is truly the culmination of everyone working together to welcome the world and help them on their journey to fall in love with Scotch whisky.” 

Meanwhile, Annika Schneider, PA to the Chief Executive at The Scotch Whisky Experience, received the Rising Star Awardsponsored by HIT Scotland. This new award recognises the achievements of passionate and enthusiastic individuals at the start of their careers in tourism and hospitality. 

Susan Morrison added: “We are incredibly proud of Annika and delighted that with the Rising Star award, she has the recognition that she deserves.

“From day one, she has been a joy to work with, an amazing colleague and addition to The Scotch Whisky Experience team. Inquisitive and creative, Annika epitomises our values and is a worthy Rising Star award winner! 

Amanda Wrathall from the EICC, won the Tourism Individual of the Year award. This award celebrates individuals who act as ambassadors for change within the industry, showcasing a commitment to tourism as a force for good.  

The judges highlighted Amanda’s genuine love for her job and her industry and has a significant record of achievement.  

Amanda is an Edinburgh local with over 30 years of experience in the hospitality and events industry, starting her career as a banqueting waitress to her current role as Sales and Marketing Director at the Edinburgh International Conference Centre.

 On receiving the award, Amanda said: “To be recognised in this particular category is incredibly humbling. Tourism in Scotland thrives because of the multitude of talented and passionate people who choose to work in this brilliant sector.  

“Whilst individual recognition is gratifying, for me, this award is shaped and shared with the inspirational colleagues I have been fortunate enough to work with over the last 35 years.” 

VisitScotland Regional Director Neil Christison said: Huge congratulations to all our regional winners for this incredible achievement.  

It is fantastic to see such recognition for the region’s vibrant tourism offering, as well as the passionate and dedicated individuals who work within it.   

“I wish everyone the best of luck for the national final in November where they will be representing Edinburgh.” 

The Scottish Thistle Awards champion innovation, collaboration, and sustainable practices, in line with the ambitions of the national tourism strategy, Scotland Outlook 2030.      

Responsible tourism is at the heart of the Scottish Thistle Awards, supporting the aim for Scotland to be recognised globally as a leader in this field. Entrants to all categories must evidence how they have embraced best practice covering the four key areas of a low carbon economy, inclusivity, thriving communities and Scotland’s natural and cultural heritage.     

In addition to the Central and East Scotland Thistle Awards, VisitScotland delivers the West of Scotland Thistle Awards. The regional awards programme also includes the Highlands & Islands Thistle Awards (HITA), the Aberdeen City and Shire Thistle Awards (ACSTA) and the South of Scotland Thistle Awards.

This year’s national sponsors of the Scottish Thistle Awards include headline sponsor, Johnstons of Elgin, as well as Abbey UK, LNER, The Macallan Estate, STV, Jacobite Loch Ness Cruises, Historic Scotland, and Fishers. The Scottish Thistle Awards also includes a media partnership with News Scotland including The Times Scotland and the Scottish Sun.   

For a full list of shortlisted finalists, please visit: www.scottishthistleawards.co.uk

PICTURES: Connor Mollison

Regional shortlist unveiled for Scottish Thistle Awards  

THE regional shortlist for Scotland’s premier tourism and events industry awards has been announced. 

The Scottish Thistle Awards, with headline sponsor Johnstons of Elgin, celebrate the very best of the tourism and events industry, which is worth £11.5 billion to the Scottish economy. 

42 tourism businesses, events and individuals are in the running to receive the prestigious award, as the shortlist for the regional finals is revealed. 

Camera Obscura & the World of Illusions is among the businesses shortlisted in the Central and East Scotland Thistle Awards. It is shortlisted in the Best Visitor Attraction category, sponsored by The Scottish Sun, alongside Edinburgh Zoo.  

The attraction is also in the running for the Inclusive Tourism category sponsored by Historic Environment Scotland, celebrating a business that has a developed an outstanding welcome for all customers and provides accessible facilities which can enjoyed by all customers. 

Camera Obscura & the World of Illusions is also shortlisted in the Innovation in Tourism category, which celebrates those driving forward positive chance and creatively adapting to consumer behaviour, alongside Glenkinchie Distillery in East Lothian.  

East Lothian Cottages in Haddington and Edinburgh Science are both in the running for the Climate Action Award category, sponsored by the Times, which celebrates businesses, events and destinations that have demonstrable progress on their journey to Net Zero.  

And Foxlake Adventures in Dunbar, A Wee Pedal in Edinburgh and Ocean Vertical in Dunbar are shortlisted in the Best Outdoor or Adventure Experience category.  

The Original Rossyln Inn in Midlothian is shortlisted in the Best Bar or Pub category, alongside Cocktail Mafia in Edinburgh. Drift in North Berwick is shortlisted in the Best Eating Experience category and Whitekirk Hill, also in North Berwick, in the Best Self Catering Experience category. 

Fraser MacDonald from Preston Mill, National Trust for Scotland, East Linton,  Katie Scott, Real Mary King’s Close, Edinburgh and Andy Cuthbertson, New Lanark Trust, Lanark are shortlisted in the Tourism Individual of the Year  category. 

The Scottish Thistle Awards are delivered by VisitScotland in partnership with regional awards programmes.

The five different regional award ceremonies will take place in September, October and November before the regional winners go through to battle it out for a national accolade at the National Final in December.  

The awards champion innovation, collaboration and sustainable practices, in line with the ambitions of the national tourism strategy, Outlook 2030.   

Responsible tourism is at the heart of the Scottish Thistle Awards, supporting the aim for Scotland to be recognised globally as a leader in this field.   

Every entry was required to provide clear evidence on how their business addresses responsible tourism, with new categories such as the Celebrating Thriving Communities Award, Inclusive Tourism Award and Climate Action Award introduced this year.  

There are 14 regional categories and 3 national-only categories. 

2023 saw more than 600 entries submitted, including almost 1200 nominations from members of the public keen to give hotels, restaurants, B&Bs, visitor attractions and individuals the opportunity to earn the recognition they deserve in the part they play in making Scotland such a fantastic place to visit.   

Steven Walker, Chair of the Scottish Thistle Awards industry panel, said: “The Scottish Thistle Awards mark an important celebration of the best in our industry.

“They showcase the vest best of Scotland’s tourism and events sector, helping to ensure that tourism, and the individuals who work in the industry, are recognised for the positive impact they bring to the country and our communities.  

“Every one of the shortlisted regional finalists is supporting our ambition to make Scotland a better place for people to live and visit. On behalf of the panel, I would like to congratulate all regional finalists and wish each and every one of them the very best of luck at the regional finals and beyond.”  

VisitScotland Regional Director Neil Christison said: “It is fantastic to see such a strong representation from Edinburgh and the Lothians in the regional finals of the Scottish Thistle Awards.  

“These entries show the strength and depth of the tourism offer in the city and surrounding area, from quality visitor attractions and experiences to examples of collaboration and innovation, and much more! I wish all those shortlisted the very best of luck at the West of Scotland Thistle Awards.” 

For almost 30 years, the Scottish Thistle Awards have helped shine a spotlight on individual businesses, people and partnerships working.  

After a two-year break due to the COVID-19 pandemic, they returned with a bang last year, culminating in the crowning of 17 winners at the National Final in February 2023.    

This year, they also include a media partnership with News Scotland.  

In addition to the Central and East Thistle Awards, VisitScotland delivers the West of Scotland Thistle Awards. The regional awards programme also includes the Highlands & Islands Thistle Awards (HITA), the Aberdeen City and Shire Thistle Awards (ACSTA) and, for the first time this year, the South of Scotland Thistle Awards. This year’s sponsors of the Scottish Thistle Awards include headline sponsor, Johnstons of Elgin, and Fishers, The Macallan Estate, STV and Abbey UK.  

Regional finals will take place in different locations around Scotland. 

  • The Central & East Thistle Awards will take place at the Sheraton Grand in Edinburgh on 21 September 2023. 
  • The Aberdeen City and Shire Regional Final, organised by Aberdeen City and Shire Tourism Awards, will take place at the Chester Hotel, Aberdeen, on 22 September.   
  • The West of Scotland Thistle Awards will take place at the Radisson Blu in Glasgow on 28 September 2023. 
  • The South of Scotland Thistle Awards, organised by the South of Scotland Destination Alliance and supported by South of Scotland Enterprise, will take place at The Cairndale Hotel in Dumfries on 5 October 2023.  
  • The Highlands and Islands Thistle Awards, organised by the Highlands and Islands Tourism Awards, will take place at the The Drumossie Hotel in Inverness on 10 November 2023.  

The full 14 regional categories are:  

  • Best B&B or Guest House Experience, sponsored by Abbey UK  
  • Best Bar or Pub 
  • Best Eating Experience 
  • Best Hotel Experience, sponsored by Fishers 
  • Best Outdoor or Adventure Experience 
  • Best Self-Catering Accommodation Experience 
  • Best Visitor Attraction, sponsored by The Scottish Sun  
  • Celebrating Thriving Communities Award  
  • Outstanding Cultural Event or Festival 
  • Inclusive Tourism Award sponsored by Historic Environment Scotland 
  • Climate Action Award, sponsored by The Times Scotland 
  • Innovation in Tourism 
  • Tourism & Hospitality Employer of the Year 
  • Tourism Individual of the Year  

The three national only categories are Outstanding Sporting Event, Best Business Event and Best Luxury Experience.