Highest ever number of ‘excellent’ Scottish bathing waters

  • 98% of Scotland’s bathing waters pass environmental standards:
    • 38 (44%) of bathing waters will be rated ‘excellent’ for 2023 – the highest since tighter standards first came into force in 2015.47 (54%) will achieve ‘good’ or ‘sufficient’ status for 2023
    • Two (2%) will have ‘poor’ status for 2023
    • Previous projects to improve water quality are now showing sustained improvements across Scotland
  • Ayr (South Beach) maintains ‘good’ status following significant improvements over many years.
  • Management plans at Dhoon Bay improved water quality in 2022.
  • Projects are in development for the two ‘poor’ Fife beaches to improve water quality
  • Farmers and land managers have continued to show good compliance with environmental regulations.
  • Targeted investments by Scottish Water have helped to reduce risks and improve water quality.

Scotland’s bathing water quality continues to improve with 38 out of 87 (44%) rated as ‘excellent’ for 2023. This is the highest number ever and highlights sustained improvements in bathing water quality, achieved through partnership projects.

Overall bathing water quality has seen ongoing improvements since 2015, when tighter standards first came into force. For next season, 85 sites will meet or exceed the sufficient classification.

Since 2015, 15 bathing waters have improved their classification from ‘poor’ to ‘sufficient’ or better. This is testament to the on-going partnership working taking place to drive forward water quality in Scotland. Whilst next year two bathing waters will have a ‘poor’ classification, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) intends to drive the same improvements that have successfully been achieved at other sites.

Scotland’s results(*):

 2022/232021/222020/212019/202018/192017/182016/172015/16
Excellent38 (44%)32 (38%)Results carried over29 (34%28 (32%)25 (29%)26 (31%)17 (20%)
Good35 (40%)35 (41%)31 (36%)35 (41%)34 (40%)36 (43%)38 (45%)
Sufficient12 (14%)17 (20%)20 (24%)13 (15%)16 (19%)11 (13%)12 (14%)
Poor2 (2%)1 (1%)5 (6%)10 (12%)11 (13%)11 (13%)17 (20%)
Total87858586868484

Sources of pollution at Scotland’s bathing waters are often complex and interlinked, requiring action from a range of organisations and people. Progress is being made through working with partners and communities to coordinate activities and identify actions to address water quality challenges, particularly around diffuse pollution, sewage and urban sources.   

One of Scotland’s most popular visitor areas, Ayr (South Beach), will maintain its ‘good’ status, achieved in 2021/22, following targeted improvement actions to reduce pollution. The status of the water quality is the result of several years of partnership working between SEPA, Ayrshire livestock farmers and Scottish Water, supported by South Ayrshire Council and the Scottish Government. These improvements were significant and there is good confidence that a similar classification should be maintained in future years.

Dhoon Bay has achieved ‘sufficient’ status for 2023. Rated ‘poor’ for the last four years, the improved water quality is a result of targeted action. This involved partnership working between the local community and tourism businesses, Scottish Water, and the local authority and focused on improvements to the treatment of private sewage as well as reducing run-off from agricultural land.

The Scottish Government provided funding to address inputs from private sewage treatment systems. This work is ongoing.

Other long-term projects

At Sandyhills, in Dumfries and Galloway, SEPA worked with farmers and NFU Scotland to tackle issues related to diffuse pollution, leading to sustained improvements to water quality. Having previously been rated ‘poor’, Sandyhills has achieved two successive ‘good’ classifications and will be rated ‘good’ again in 2023.

Heads of Ayr in Ayrshire has achieved an ‘excellent’ and ‘good’ classification in the last two seasons, following ‘poor’ classifications in previous years. It will maintain its ‘good’ again in 2023. It has seen investment in sewage treatment, surface water drainage and farms complying with requirements. This has resulted in significant water quality improvement.

The Nairn Central and Nairn East bathing waters will be rated ‘good’ for 2023. These sites have had consistent ratings since passing in 2018. Having been a priority project, progress was made through working with partners and communities to coordinate activities and identify actions to address water quality challenges, particularly around diffuse pollution, sewage and urban sources.

Luss Bay will be ‘sufficient’ for the 2023 bathing season and improvements in the water quality in what is a very popular area for visitors will be taken forward by SEPA with partner organisations including Argyll & Bute Council, the Luss Estate, Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority, Scottish Water, local businesses and residents.

Scotland had two newly designated Bathing Waters in 2022.

Barassie in Ayrshire achieved a ‘sufficient’ classification, while Lower Largo, in Fife, will be rated as ‘poor’ for the 2023 bathing season. A Scottish Water project at Lower Largo has been assessing potential sources of pollution into local burns, including testing for misconnections in nearby properties. SEPA will continue to monitor and report water quality and determine how best to drive water quality improvements over the next few years.

Kinghorn (Harbour Beach) will be rated as ‘poor’ for 2023, following ‘sufficient’ classifications in 2019 and 2021. SEPA is carrying out investigations and further monitoring is planned. SEPA will work with partners to identify and resolve issues.

Ruth Stidson, SEPA’s Principal Scientist for Bathing Waters, said: “Seeing the long-term bathing water quality improvements reflected in this year’s results demonstrates that the sustained hard work by public bodies, private businesses and communities has made a real improvement across Scotland.

“More of our bathing waters will be rated ‘excellent’ than ever before and, overall, 98% are meeting strict environmental standards. We have the largest number of designated bathing waters on record which is good news for the increasing popularity of wild swimming and the communities, businesses and visitors who enjoy our coastlines.

“This has demonstrated the success of driving improvements in water quality through targeted regulation and partnership working. SEPA will continue to work to protect and improve water quality across Scotland with a range of stakeholders, including local authorities, public bodies, farmers and local communities and businesses. We will use our expertise to provide advice and guidance, recommend actions and – when it is appropriate to do so – take robust enforcement action.”

Environment Minister Mairi McAllan said: “Scotland’s bathing waters are not only important to our environment, they provide spaces for recreation and contribute to good health and well-being. That’s why it’s so great to see more bathing waters across the country rated excellent than ever before.

“The number of bathing waters in Scotland has increased since last year and now stands at 87, with 98% achieving the bathing water quality standards.

“By investing in improving bathing waters across Scotland, we have made sure many more people – tourists and locals alike – can continue to enjoy them, which is good for our communities and our local economies.” 

Simon Parsons, Director of Strategic Customer Service Planning, Scottish Water, said:“Scottish Water is committed to continuing to support the protection and improvement of Scotland’s rivers, coastal waters and beaches.    

“Last December, we published our improving urban waters route map announcing plans to invest up to half a billion pounds more in Scotland’s waste water network to deliver further improvements and ensure that Scotland’s rivers, beaches and urban waters are free from sewage related debris.  

“Our customers can play a huge part in preventing debris in rivers and on beaches. Our national campaign ‘Nature Calls’ urges customers not to flush wet wipes (and other items) down the toilet and we are calling for a complete ban on the sale of wet wipes containing plastic.”

Working with farmers to improve Scotland’s rivers

SEPA has been working alongside NFU Scotland over a number of years to help farmers and rural land managers across Scotland reduce diffuse pollution.

This has been an issue affecting both Ayrshire and Rockcliffe bathing water catchments. In the Ayr (South Beach) bathing water catchment there are only a handful of farms SEPA is still working with to achieve compliance.

All others are fully compliant, with many adopting new practices and spending significant sums of money to improve slurry storage, fence off water courses and install alternative water supplies for livestock.

Around £50 million has been spent on improvements in Ayrshire’s Bathing waters, through self-funding and grants from Scottish Government, and in many cases, farmers have gone even further than is legally required to help protect Scotland’s water environment from farming activities.

In 2022, SEPA issued a farmer with a £600 fixed monetary penalty for a failure to comply with or contravene a General Binding rule. The farmer, who had previously been compliant, failed to prevent significant erosion or poaching of land within 5m of the Corraford Burn, which is within the Dhoon catchment.

Bathing water quality monitoring and prediction

Scotland has some of the most beautiful beaches in the world, but also experiences some of the wettest weather in Europe. Heavy rain can have an impact on water quality at bathing waters due to pollutants being washed into rivers from sewage treatment systems, roads and pavements. 

Scotland’s official bathing water season runs between 1 June and 15 September. Throughout the season, SEPA’s specialist teams sample the designated waters providing regular water quality information which is published on the SEPA website. Pre-season sampling is carried out during May.

Monitoring water quality in this way means SEPA can provide information on water quality for bathing and develop a strategy for any water quality improvements needed.

Electronic messaging signs, at selected bathing waters across Scotland, provide real-time predictions of water quality during the season.

Highland and Islands - 8 excellent, 7 good, 1 sufficient, 0 poor  
 
Achmelvich          Excellent  
Dores     Sufficient
Dornoch                  Excellent
Dunnet  Excellent
Ettrick   Bay            Good
Findhorn                 Excellent
Gairloch Beach   Excellent
Ganavan                 Excellent
Loch Morlich       Excellent
Lossiemouth (East)  Good
Machrihanish      Good
Nairn (Central)   Good
Nairn (East)         Good
Rosemarkie         Good
Sand Beach          Excellent
Thurso   Good
    
Lothian, mid Scotland and Fife - 10 excellent, 3 good, 2 sufficient, 2 poor  
Aberdour (Silversands)   Excellent
Aberdour Harbour (Black Sands)  Good
Anstruther (Billow Ness)           Excellent
Burntisland          Good
Crail (Roome Bay)           Excellent
Elie (Harbour) and Earlsferry  Excellent
Elie (Ruby Bay)  Excellent
Kinghorn (Harbour Beach)  Poor
Kinghorn (Pettycur)         Excellent
Kingsbarns           Excellent
Kirkcaldy (Seafield)  Excellent
Leven     Sufficient
Lower LargoPoor
Portobello (Central)         Good
Portobello  (West)             Sufficient
St Andrews (East Sands)  Excellent
St Andrews (West Sands)  Excellent
    
North East Scotland – 11 excellent, 6 good, 0 sufficient, 0 poor  
Aberdeen            Excellent
Arbroath (West Links)     Good
Balmedie                Excellent
Broughty Ferry   Excellent
Carnoustie           Good
Collieston               Good
Cruden Bay          Good
Cullen Bay              Excellent
Fraserburgh (Philorth)    Excellent
Fraserburgh (Tiger Hill)    Excellent
Inverboyndie      Excellent
Lunan Bay            Excellent
Monifieth               Good
Montrose               Excellent
Peterhead (Lido)            Excellent
Rosehearty          Excellent
Stonehaven        Good
    
Solway – 1 excellent, 5 good, 1 sufficient, 0 poor  
Brighouse Bay  Good
Carrick  Good
Dhoon Bay  Sufficient
Mossyard  Excellent
Rockcliffe  Good
Sandyhills  Good
Southerness  Good
    
South East Scotland - 7 excellent, 5 good, 3 sufficient, 0 poor  
Broad Sands        Good
Coldingham         Excellent
Dunbar (Belhaven)           Good
Dunbar (East)     Good
Yellow Craig         Sufficient
Eyemouth            Sufficient
Gullane  Excellent
Longniddry          Good
North Berwick (Milsey Bay)           Sufficient
North Berwick (West)     Excellent
Pease Bay             Excellent
Seacliff  Excellent
Seton Sands        Good
Thorntonloch      Excellent
Whitesands         Excellent
    
West Scotland – 1 excellent, 9 good, 5 sufficient, 0 poor  
Ayr (South Beach)             Good
Barassie BaySufficient
Culzean  Good
Girvan  Sufficient
Heads of Ayr  Good
Irvine     Sufficient
Largs (Pencil Beach)         Good
Lunderston Bay  Good
Luss Bay                  Sufficient
Maidens  Sufficient
Millport Bay        Good
Prestwick  Excellent
Saltcoats/Ardrossan        Good
Seamill   Good
Troon (South Beach)  Good

Forth Ports poured cold water on Wardie Bay wild swimming plans

Following a Freedom of Information request the Scottish Government has released the following submission from Forth Ports:

Wardie Bay was not included on the list of Scotland’s designated bathing waters when it was published on 1st July.

The Wardie Bay Beachwatch environmental group appealed the decision and received the following response from the Scottish Government’s Environmental Quality Unit last month:

Thank you for your letter to Mairi Gougeon, Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and Islands, about the application for Bathing Waters designation at Wardie Bay, Edinburgh. Bathing Waters fall under the remit of Mairi McAllan, Minister for Environment, Biodiversity and Land Reform, and I have been asked to reply.

The Bathing Waters Review Panel is multi-stakeholder group, chaired by SEPA, that considers and reviews the list of bathing waters, including new applications for designation and provides recommendations to Scottish Ministers. The Panel met on 8 December 2020 and made recommendations to the Minister for Wardie Bay bathing water designation application in May 2021.

The panel recognised numerous positive aspects of the Wardie Bay application and agreed that user number criteria was met in 2020 and seemed sustainable. However, Forth Ports provided a submission which mentioned swimmer safety in relation to offshore vessel/harbour activity, and this would have to be managed by clear beach management and bather information.

The relevant local authority, City of Edinburgh Council, indicated overall support in principle for the application. However, despite the Transport and Environment committee outcomes you mention in your letter, there are still on-going discussions at Committee level on their current roles and resource to perform beach management functions.

As beach management is a key criteria for designation, until such times as the City of Edinburgh Council concludes its deliberations on these matters, the Panel was unable to recommend designation.

Having considered the Panel’s advice on the circumstances at Wardie Bay, the Minister accepted the Panel’s recommendation that Wardie Bay is not designated as a bathing water at this time, noting that the outcome of the Council’s current deliberations on beach management will inform the Panel’s future recommendation regarding this location.

I hope you find this information helpful.

The group’s petition to have Wardie Bay included on the list of designated bathing waters remains live on Change.org – over 1730 people have signed so far.

We’re campaigning for Wardie Bay to be included in Scotland’s list of designated Bathing Waters

In 2019, the Wardie Bay Wild Ones wild swimmers and Wardie Bay Beachwatch applied to SEPA for designated Bathing Water status for Wardie Bay.

We have been working hard to help generate support for this important cause for both recreational users and marine life. We would love if you could please read, sign and share our petition, which achieved 1,000 signatures in its first four days.

Please support our campaign film

#WardieBay4BathingWater

 We are also making a film, working with videographer, Carlos Hernan. We would like to pay him a professional fee for supporting us in these difficult times.
Please click here for information.

Thank you!

Make a Donation!