The Scottish Parliament’s Health, Care and Sport Committee says it is concerned about the “scant details” behind government plans to overhaul the NHS.
In a letter published on Friday, the Committee says proposals expected to substantially change health board structures have been made without a clear evidence base or assessment of how much they will cost.
The Committee has been scrutinising health, care and sport spending ahead of the Scottish Government’s Budget announcement on 3 December.
At its final evidence session, Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care Angela Constance told MSPs on the Committee that she had come to the “very strong conclusion” that Scotland’s current 14 NHS boards should be reduced to two.
In its subsequent letter to Ms Constance, the Committee calls for greater clarity and transparency and is urging the Scottish Government to publish the evidence it is basing its proposals on.
Committee Convener, Helen McDade MSP, said: “Given the significant and substantial implications of the proposed changes to the NHS, we would expect to have full information available on the scope, costs, engagement and evidence base, instead of the scant details we have been able to access.
“It appears to the Committee, that decisions have been made by the government to substantially reform our health service before a business case was developed, before a comprehensive consultation process took place or a clear indication of the impact the reform will have on patients and staff.”
The letter also sets out the Committee’s support for ensuring social care staff are paid at the same rate as NHS workers.
Other issues highlighted include the immediate pressures faced in the health, care and sport sectors. The Committee asks the government to “clearly state” how reform will help achieve improvement in areas including financial sustainability, waiting times, workforce pressures, maintenance and buildings and predicted demographic changes.
Photography for Friends of the Earth Scotland from: Colin Hattersley Photography – www.colinhattersley.com
Over six thousand people joined a march in Edinburgh yesterday in a major demonstration against AI data centres across Scotland.
Campaigners are demanding that the Scottish Government publicly consult on plans for AI data centres before any are approved, in a ‘national conversation’ where people across Scotland can have their say.
Over 80 organisations and groups backed the march – including community campaigners affected by AI data centre proposals in their local areas, climate organisations, trade unions and anti-poverty charities.
The march is part of a Europe wide wave of protests to ‘stop dirty data centres’ with other actions in Denmark, the Netherlands, Spain, Ireland and many other countries having happened earlier in November.
Yesterday’s protest coincided with a Global Day of Action around the UN climate talks COP31 in Antalya, Turkey.
Photography for Friends of the Earth Scotland from: Colin Hattersley Photography – www.colinhattersley.com
There are over 20 proposals for AI data centres of different sizes and in various stages of planning across Scotland. Campaigners have warned that if all the proposals were granted permission by the Scottish Government, data centres could become the most polluting sector in the country by 2030 and endanger Scotland’s climate commitments.
Friends of the Earth Scotland senior campaigner Kim Pratt commented: “Thousands came out to demand that the people of Scotland can have their say on these monstrous AI data centres.
“Community groups facing down these projects were joined by environmental, anti-poverty and anti-war organisations and artists, demonstrating that this is an issue that is important to everyone.
“The huge data centres being proposed would crowd out communities, double Scotland’s electricity demand and make our energy bills more expensive, as well as trashing our climate commitments and using thousands of tonnes of precious materials, such as nickel and copper.
“The Scottish Government has failed to explain why it thinks AI data centres are needed in Scotland and how it will protect people from their harms. We’ve seen how normal people suffer when big tech is allowed to push through their data centre plans in other countries – the same thing cannot be allowed to happen here.
“That’s why we are demanding that people are given a say on AI data centres in Scotland before any decisions are made.”
Sarah Finlay, from the West Edinburgh Against AI Data Centres group who face a 200MW development on green belt land at Hermiston: We’re parents, neighbours and ordinary people who care about where we live and the future of Scotland.
“Today showed that what started for us as a local fight in West Edinburgh has become a nationwide movement against US tech billionaires. We cannot allow them to dictate the future of our countryside and our communities, they do not bring the benefits that many developers, tech firms and Donald Trump would lead us to believe.
“We are asking the Scottish Government to stand shoulder to shoulder with us and not let this happen. Big tech, go hame tae think again!”
Photography for Friends of the Earth Scotland from: Colin Hattersley Photography – www.colinhattersley.com
Sam Gibson, a Dumfries and Galloway resident who is campaigning against the Chapelcross AI data centre: “We marched to say that we don’t want AI data centres in Scotland. The Annan and wider Dumfries and Galloway communities have let it be known that we do not want a data centre here or anywhere else.
“We are calling on the Scottish Government to call in the Chapelcross data centre application, and to press the brakes on AI data centre developments across the country. The risks of these developments are numerous and serious. The health and voices of our communities matter.”
Photography for Friends of the Earth Scotland from: Colin Hattersley Photography – www.colinhattersley.com
Kat Jones, Director of Action to Protect Rural Scotland said: “Today we sent a clear message to the Scottish Government.
“It must stop ignoring the calls from civil society to be involved in discussions around the future of hyperscale AI data centres in Scotland.
“We have had enough of hearing how the data centre developers have had a hotline to the decision makers while communities and environmental organisation are excluded. Now let us have our say!”
Photography for Friends of the Earth Scotland from: Colin Hattersley Photography – www.colinhattersley.com cphattersley@gmail.com
Kate Ireland, a poet from Glasgow who performed at the rally: “I’m scared about the arts, I’m scared about our jobs, our livelihoods, and I’m scared for the essential green spaces in Scotland.
“The climate crisis should be our number one priority as people on this earth, and these computer generated monoliths are the exact opposite of a thriving natural world.
“But I’m hopeful in the power of the people, the monster is unmasking, making itself so apparent it’s impossible to ignore, and we will rise up together to show it that we never needed it in the first place.”